Research shows contractors prepared to go to tribunal over IR35 extension

Six in 10 contractors says they are willing to take clients to tribunal for incorrect determinations under off-payroll rules set to be rolled out to the private sector from April.

The findings come from contracting authority ContractorCalculator, which surveyed 12,327 contractors to understand the consequences of the extension on the contracting population.

The findings, released this morning, also reveal:

  • 54% claim firms are unlawfully deducting their new tax bills from workers’ pay
  • 62% claim clients have not provided a Status Determination Statement (SDS)
  • 58% say they are willing to take clients to Employment Tribunal over incorrect treatment
  • 23% expect to quit contracting due to IR35, and 21% intend to change career.

With regards to HMRC’s Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST), the research found just 2% of contractors consider that tool reflects the law, while 79% of contractors claim they do not trust HMRC to stand by the results of the tool and 72% do not trust its accuracy. 

Other key findings include:

  • 69% of contractors consider that CEST is unfair
  • 58% of contractors claim companies are not adhering to reasonable care
  • 68% of contractors say they were not even involved in their own assessment process
  • Only 38% claim they were given a Status Determination Statement (SDS) – despite this being a legal requirement under the new rules.

Commenting on the findings, Dave Chaplin, CEO of ContractorCalculator and IR35 Shield, said: “The devastation is happening now and the findings of our survey speak volumes. Contractors are out of work and are abandoning their clients. The flexible workforce is being destroyed because many firms are not ready, do not understand how to navigate the legislation and are acting non-compliantly, primarily because they have been let down by HMRC’s lack of guidance and because final legislation has still not been published. Businesses will suffer as will the UK economy as work moves offshore and contractors’ careers and livelihoods are destroyed.
“The fallout will be damaging for many parties, as cases are litigated, firms’ costs increase, the self-employed suffer considerably reduced income, and mobility of the workforce is severely hampered.

“The Conservative Party, which purports to be the party of business, has created a political crisis that, in one fell swoop, is set to decimate both a valuable flexible workforce and damage the UK economy for the long term. The findings of our survey provide overwhelming proof from 12,000 affected contractors that this policy needs to be cancelled. 

“The government cannot ignore this overwhelming evidence and must, instead, delay and rethink. A simple Off-Payroll tax of about 5% across the board would remove the need for the complex employment status test which is wreaking havoc – and 79% of contractors agree with that simple idea.”

Addison Lee drivers are workers says Court of Appeal

In the latest victory for gig economy workers, the Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal by hired driving company Addison Lee.

Legislation 23 April 2021

Cadbury’s call to exclude umbrellas could ‘shut down’ industry

An MP has called for changes to the Finance Bill which would, if approved, effectively shut down the UK umbrella industry.

Legislation 14 April 2021

SSGC launches WLTS to deliver ex-service personnel to businesses

Specialist security guard provider SSGC has launched a new initiative to deliver temporary labour and recruitment services to businesses.

New to Market 13 April 2021


This week’s new contracts & deals include: Bowler Bentley Recruitment, Major Recruitment

Contracts 12 April 2021