Private sector off-payroll rules throws up admin nightmare for HR professionals

Almost half of HR professionals report that they are drowning in paperwork due to the “administrative nightmare” of off-payroll rules being extended into the private sector from April next year.

The research from next generation management consultancy Procorre, of 500 UK HR professionals, reveals 47% say since the changes to IR35 regulations in the private sector were announced they’ve been “drowning in paperwork”, while half (50%) said they’ve found it difficult to concentrate on other tasks, and that planning for the changes has “taken over their time” (47%).

The cost of this administrative burden is seeing 27% of those surveyed spending between £200k to £499,999 to prepare for the changes. 

Meanwhile, separate data obtained from the Office for National Statistics and released this week by global payroll and contractor accountancy firm Access Financial shows the number of IT contractors has increased nearly every year since the 2008 financial crisis but declined by 2.4% in 2018, from 125,012 to 121,989.

This week has also seen HM Revenue & Customs issue its latest guidance around the extension of the rules into the private sector, which has been attacked by IR35 specialist Qdos CEO Seb Maley as failing to address concerns around its CEST tool or specific rules around how a contractor can overturn an unfair IR35 decision.

“With this in mind, private sector firms that rely on contractors and want to continue benefitting from engaging these workers compliantly outside IR35 would be wise to seek specialist advice.”

Maley highlighted the section in the guidance, which states: ‘This reform does not prevent people from working through their own limited companies and does not affect the self-employed. Contractors who are following the existing rules correctly will feel little impact.

He commented: “This is only true if the client determines IR35 status accurately. While we are confident many private sector firms will do this in time, to say reform will barely impact IR35 compliant contractors and the self-employed ignores the fact thousands of genuinely self-employed workers were wrongly placed inside IR35 in the public sector.”

• Comment below on this story. You can also tweet us to tell us your thoughts or share this story with a friend. Our editorial email is

Biggest drop in job vacancies in 10 years and employment also down

UK unemployment fell in the quarter to September but so did the number of people in work, according to official figures.

12 November 2019


This week’s contracts and deals include: iKas International, Retorio, Sanderson, Workday

Contracts 12 November 2019


This week’s launches include: Kronos, Oliver James

New to Market 12 November 2019

FinTech Influencers advise to recruit refugees to fill fintech talent shortages

Employers looking for talent in the UK’s burgeoning fintech sector should widen their search.

11 November 2019