HMRC refutes ContractorCalculator claims of CEST inaccuracies

HM Revenue & Customs has expressed confidence in the accuracy of its Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) as the tool has come under increasing scrutiny.

A statement from contracting authority ContractorCalculator, released this morning, claims HMRC has conceded that the tool has still not undergone any formal testing to produce detailed evidence of its accuracy claims since its release almost two years ago, despite repeated claims from HMRC and the Treasury that the tool is under continual review. HMRC had also revealed an informal assessment conducted to ensure that CEST meets the Government’s Digital Service (GDS) Standards, used “to check whether a service is good enough for public use” has also not been carried out.

Responding to a Freedom of Information request from ContractorCalculator, HMRC said: “No further documentation has been created since April 2018 where CEST has been subsequently tested against court cases,” referring to around 24 employment status cases provided in response to a previous FOI request made by ContractorCalculator in April 2018.

ContractorCalculator claims HMRC had attempted to use the single page of claims as proof of CEST’s accuracy but added their own rigorous re-testing against the 24 cases produced 511 pages of evidence which found the tool returned a flawed assessment 42% of the time. 

Commenting further, ContractorCalculator CEO Dave Chaplin said: “HMRC imposed CEST upon the public sector and by doing so has cheated many honest taxpayers out of thousands of pounds in the process with a tool that is not fit for purpose and does not work.

“We debunked HMRC’s claim that CEST is accurate and by doing so we thought that the taxman might make some effort to vindicate its tool but, two years on, we can see that CEST has been stuck in beta mode since its inception. 

“HMRC has pledged to work with stakeholders to improve CEST but the reality is that it has not been working on the tool and has continued to issue tax bills off the back of faulty results. It will be interesting to see what enhancements HMRC is planning to make in preparation for rolling out off-payroll into the private sector.”

When contacted by Recruiter this morning, an HMRC issued a statement saying the CEST tool reflected employment status case law and had been “rigorously tested” throughout its development.

“Its use is advisory and not mandatory, but we are confident in CEST’s accuracy and stand by its output when it is completed in line with our guidance.

“GDS Standards assessments are only required for transactional services, which allow users to exchange information, goods or services. As CEST is a tool for guidance purposes, not a transactional service, a GDS assessment was not appropriate.”

• Comment below on this story. You can also tweet us to tell us your thoughts or share this story with a friend. Our editorial email is

Calculate agency workers’ holiday correctly, recruiters are warned

Recruiters have been urged to ensure they calculate agency workers’ holiday pay properly.

Legislation 22 July 2019

Recruiters claim clients unaware of off-payroll rules in private sector

Less than half of recruiters think their clients are aware that off-payroll rules are set to be extended into the private sector from next April.

Legislation 22 July 2019

Recruiters can steal a march on competitors by being more flexible with their working

Recruiters who successfully introduce flexible working can guard against an exodus of talent making for the door.

Legislation 18 July 2019

Recruiters back single new body to protect workers’ employment rights

Recruiters have given their backing to government proposals for single labour market enforcement body to improve enforcement of employment rights for workers and businesses.

Legislation 18 July 2019