Sector Barometer shows signs of optimism for industry

Most recruiters are hitting or exceeding their targets, according to the latest Sector Barometer.

While the Barometer, produced by Alex Arnot, non-executive adviser to more than 20 recruitment firms, in association with Recruiter, shows industry ‘optimism’ (ie. prospects for the coming year compared with last year), ‘plans to grow headcount’ and ‘expected year-on-year profit’ are all down on Q1 2018, they are nonetheless better than they were in the last quarter of 2017.

Executive search is performing strongly with (net) almost two out of three executive search teams expecting to outperform the same quarter last year. On the flip side fewer than one in three (net) have similar expectations for their temp teams. 

The number of respondents citing rising overheads as a top three concern hit a record 23%. However, a record three-quarters of respondents cited a shortage of candidates as their top concern, and net 27% of firms noted an increase in hiring process times. Combined, these two elements highlight how important it is for recruitment companies to spend time developing new business, giving them the chance to cherry pick clients who are more likely to result in a hire.

With a steadily increasing percentage of firms experiencing rising debtor days it is good to see that a record 33% now have higher average fee rates than they did a year ago – however, 55% have not increased fee rates in the last year and 9% have seen them fall. 

Although this is the second lowest level of optimism to date, nonetheless 50% of respondents (net) are more positive about their business’ prospects for the coming year compared with 12 months ago.

With a shortage of skilled consultants still one of the top three challenges, net 56% of recruitment companies are nonetheless expecting to increase headcount in the coming quarter. 

Net 55% of respondents expect net profit for the coming 12 months to increase against the previous 12 months.

And 55% of recruitment firms hit or exceeded their revenue targets last quarter, with 40% missing their targets and 5% not setting targets.

A record 24% of respondents say they have upped their fee rates in the last year – the 76% who haven’t increased their fee rates in the last 12 months should be trying to do so!

Almost a quarter of respondents have noticed recruitment processes slowing down in the last quarter – a real indication that recruitment firms should be doing more business development in a candidate scarce market. 

While the year-on-year performance of executive search has been steadily increasing (net 61% expect next quarter to outperform the same quarter last year), the temp market remains volatile, with a record low of net 29%, down from 47% at the last quarter. It will be interesting to whether this trend continues next quarter or whether figures rebound as they did in Q3 2017. 

For the first time since the barometer began in Q1 2017 fewer than 40% of respondents cited economic conditions/uncertainty as a top three challenge. The shortage of candidates has hit a new record level at 76% and this may get worse following GDPR. There has also been a sharp rise in the number of respondents citing the cost of overheads as a top three concern. For the second quarter in a row there has been an increase in the number of firms citing a shortage of consultants as an issue.

Other challenges added by respondents to the free text field:

  • Complexity of contracts especially GDPR related
  • GDPR (x3)
  • Government regulation
  • Quality of candidates (x2)
  • Time to hire of clients/response times with regards selected candidates
  • Getting our brand into the market
  • Internal recruiters (x2)
  • Margins pressed by smaller agencies and larger ones
  • Contract finding in local or international 
  • Client communications being poor, meaning it takes longer to fill vacancies assigned to us and/or good candidates find something else
  • Government legislation and interference
  • Payment
  • Business development
  • Identifying the best technology in order to increase productivity
  • RPO and their lack of engagement

• Comment below on this story. You can also tweet us to tell us your thoughts or share this story with a friend. Our editorial email is

Three-quarters of employers struggle to find appropriate skills

Almost three-quarters of firms are struggling to find the right hire, according to the latest Quarterly Recruitment Outlook from the British Chambers of Commerce, in partnership with careers site Totaljobs.

4 February 2020

Employer confidence plummets amid Brexit uncertainty

Employer confidence in the UK economy has dropped to its joint-lowest level since mid-2016, according to the latest JobsOutlook report from the Recruitment & Employment Confederation (REC). 

30 October 2019

Siloed hiring prevents talent mix being optimised

Organisational silos are the biggest barrier to employers hiring the optimum mix of employed and non-employed talent, such as contingent workers, freelancers, independent contractors and consultants, according to a report commissioned by recruiter Alexander Mann Solutions.

15 October 2019

Jobs report finds fastest fall in permanent appointments for three years

Permanent staff appointments have declined at the quickest rate for more than three years, according to the latest KPMG and REC UK Report on Jobs.

6 September 2019