Pick the right tools rather than purport to be psychologists

I couldn’t agree more with the headline ’Stop being psychologists’ of Ben Fletcher’s article (’Bloggers with Bite’, Recruiter 15 June).

I couldn’t agree more with the headline ’Stop being psychologists’ of Ben Fletcher’s article (’Bloggers with Bite’, Recruiter 15 June). In fact, I would go further and say that it applies not just to agencies but to employers as well, because all too often neither is very good at it!

However, like many of his recruiting colleagues, Ben is missing a trick. The assessment tools to help him to help his clients truly understand who’s the best person for the job, based on ’soft skills’ (including cultural fit), are already on the market. It wouldn’t be a big leap for recruiters to start offering them as part of the recruitment package but their reasons for not doing so are manifold (we hear them all the time).

The most common reason is that the client won’t pay the extra cost. If that’s the case, they’re not really interested in cultural fit, just a not untypical ’bums on seats’ mentality. But if recruiters want to reduce the level of dissatisfaction (and cost) from placing the wrong people (even the ones with the right skills), it would be worthwhile searching out the right tools and seeing what a difference they make.

Of course, nobody should recruit purely for cultural fit but at a time when there are many potential candidates vying for every position, it’s a very valuable additional filter.

You don’t have to be a psychologist, Ben but you could certainly benefit from some of the tools of the psychologist’s trade!

Martin Goodwill, managing director, Profiles International

 

REC CEO hits back at government cuts to agency spend

Government calls to eliminate agency spend at the NHS have received a fiery response from the Recruitment & Employment Confederation.

Legislation 3 June 2025

Government health leaders threaten ‘rip-off temporary staffing agencies’

NHS trusts and integrated care boards (ICBs) are being urged by government health leaders to eradicate agency spending to build on a £1bn fall in spending in 2024-25.

Legislation 3 June 2025

£1.5bn defence spending will create highly-skilled jobs in the UK

The UK government is to create more than 1,000 new jobs as a result of a £1.5bn defence investment.

Legislation 2 June 2025

APPOINTMENTS: 27-30 MAY 2025

This week’s appointments include: ECMS, Madison Berkeley, The Education Network

People 27 May 2025
Top