Barmaid dismissal for clothing faux pas raises discrimination concerns for recruiters

Recruiters have been warned to be wary of potentially discriminatory demands from clients following a case involving a barmaid, who claimed she was dismissed for refusing to wear a bra.

The Sun reports the barmaid in question – Kate Hanna, who was employed at the Bird & Beer bar in East Yorkshire – wrote on Facebook that she was fired from her job for refusing to wear a bra. Hanna claimed an inappropriate sexual remark was made to her, while her manager dealt with the situation by telling her she would not be allowed into work in future unless she wore a bra.

For their part, in a statement on their Facebook page, Bird & Beer said they could confirm that no employees have been dismissed from the company regarding Hanna’s allegations.

The bar added it has a duty of care to protect all of its employees from any discrimination or sexual harassment within the workplace. It takes any comments towards employees very seriously and acts upon them immediately in a professional manner.

Commenting on the case, Charlotte Farrell, associate solicitor at law firm Coffin Mew, told Recruiter in a statement while responsibility to dismiss a worker normally lies with the manager taking the decision, recruiters still need to be aware of following instructions from clients that could lead to potential discrimination occurring.

“When asked to place candidates in the service sector, recruiters should be careful of instructions that an employer intends to implement a dress code for successful applicants, which could unjustifiably single out specific groups, or a request that an employer only wants a particular type of employee – ie. female, young, those with particular physical characteristics,” Farrell said.

“Such requests could be potentially discriminatory and the Equality Act 2010 specifically states that where an employment relationship is concerned, it is an offence for someone to knowingly help someone else to do something that is discriminatory. As a reminder, the protected characteristics are far reaching and cover age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, religion or belief, sex and sexual orientation.

“When asked to provide such specific candidates, recruiters should only follow such a request if completely satisfied that the company making the request has confirmed that they are not discriminating and the recruiter feels it is reasonable to follow the request. In practice, we’d always recommend this was done in writing and that the recruiter sought advice before following any instructions which could potentially be discriminatory.”

• Want to comment on this story? Email us at [email protected] or tweet us below to tell us your thoughts. We will run comments online in a round-up at the end of the week.

Email story to a friend

Hospitality recruitment drive to fill 50 roles in luxury Scottish hotel

Crossbasket Castle, a luxury hotel on the outskirts of Glasgow, is set to create 50 new jobs in the hospitality industry.

17 April 2024

NEW TO THE MARKET: 15-19 APRIL 2024

This week’s new launches include: LinkedIn, Peak 72

New to Market 15 April 2024

£60m funding as Sunak goes big on apprenticeships

Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has unveiled a raft of reforms aimed at increasing apprenticeship numbers and doing away with red tape for small businesses.

Legislation 19 March 2024

Haven’s recruitment drive offers 550+ job opportunities for 2024

Holiday park operator Haven is looking to recruit more than 550 people at its two Blackpool parks, to support an increase in bookings for the year.

7 March 2024
Top